In recent months, European natural gas prices have witnessed a notable decline, a trend driven largely by an abundance of gas stocks across the continentHowever, this situation may not reflect a stable norm for the futureThe underlying causes of Europe’s structural gas shortages have merely receded temporarily, indicating that the potential for rapid price surges in the gas market has not entirely dissipated.

Current data reflects a continued downward trajectory in natural gas prices in Europe as of early MarchThe Title Transfer Facility (TTF) forward price averaged around $15.7 per million British thermal units (MMBtu), showcasing a stark contrast to the average prices recorded in 2022. Specifically, this figure marks a 60% decrease compared to the prices observed in late 2022 and early 2023. Reflecting on this significant drop, various national media outlets have published articles proclaiming a resolution to the energy crisis that was exacerbated by ongoing military conflicts

Advertisements

Nonetheless, I harbor reservations regarding these assertionsIt is my contention that Europe's gas supply challenges have only been momentarily alleviated, while the fundamental issues fueling the gas crisis remain largely intact.

The recent decline in European gas prices is attributed primarily to diminishing liquefied natural gas (LNG) imports from Asia, coupled with Europe's high inventory levelsAt the beginning of March, Europe's gas storage facilities boasted a filling rate of 61%, significantly above the five-year average of 41% for the same periodThe seasonal nature of energy consumption in Europe plays a crucial role, with peak demand predominantly occurring in summer and winter monthsThe necessity for heating in Northwestern Europe during winter typically spikes gas consumption to more than double the summer levelsThis seasonal fluctuation underscores the importance of gas storage in determining market prices

Advertisements

Fortunately, a combination of an unusually mild winter, substantial energy conservation efforts from households, and weakened industrial demand has culminated in a favorable gas storage scenario this winter, helping Europe navigate a potentially severe gas crisis.

Yet, the pivotal question arises: can these favorable conditions persist over time? I am inclined to think that the likelihood of this happening remains low.

Firstly, the weak demand for LNG imports in China over the preceding months was significantly shaped by the impacts of stringent COVID-19 policies on the economyWhile rising LNG prices did contribute to curtailing imports, they were not the primary factorWith the recent pivotal adjustments to China’s pandemic response, economic recovery has accelerated rapidlyDespite the central government’s annual growth target being set at 5%, market predictions for 2023 suggest a more optimistic consensus at around 5.5%. This swift resurgence of the economy is likely to catalyze increased natural gas consumption in China

Advertisements

Additionally, its recovery is poised to influence surrounding East Asian economies, thereby indirectly boosting gas consumption across these regionsIt’s also important to note that the JKM gas price has seen a considerable decline, which reduces the price dampening effect on gas consumptionHence, the LNG import demand from China and other major Asian countries may not replicate 2022's weakness in 2023 and 2024.

Secondly, temperature variations serve as a critical gauge for fluctuations in Europe's natural gas consumption, particularly the extremes of summer heat and winter coldThe winter of 2022 was among the mildest recorded in the past fifty years, with average daily temperatures ranking among the highest over this spanThis moderation significantly lessened the winter demand for gasHowever, there exists no compelling evidence or justification suggesting that winter 2023 and 2024 will maintain similar warmth

• The Perils of Pump and Dump Manipulation
• Fed's Tight Grip on Inflation Amid Trade Slowdown
• Economic Data Weighs on U.S. Treasury Yields
• BTL: The Largest Money Market ETF
• GDX: A Prominent Precious Metals ETF

Should we assume that these upcoming winters revert to the average temperature levels observed throughout the past decade, this would likely trigger a marked increase in gas withdrawals from storage, precipitating a significant decline in filling rates.

Thirdly, while the present context of lower gas prices has led to short-term weaknesses in Europe's industrial sectors—with some production lines temporarily halting and demand stifled—this scenario will struggle to become a lasting normThe ongoing restructuring of global supply chains may curtail industrial gas demand in the medium to long term, yet it may not yield immediate effects in the short run.

Taking the aforementioned points into account, it can be concluded that the currently ample gas storage levels are unlikely to establish a reliable status quo

Thus, the underlying conditions that could trigger a resurgence in European gas prices have not entirely vanished.

Moreover, the global natural gas industry confronts several other potential disruptive factors that should not be underestimated when considering future price movements.

On the demand side, uncertainty looms, amplifying the risk of a supply-demand imbalance in 2023 and 2024. Firstly, China's vigorous economic recovery will likely enhance LNG importsIn 2022, the volume of pipeline gas imported by Europe from Russia dropped dramatically to 61.7 billion cubic meters, a reduction of 78 billion cubic meters year-on-yearOne of the primary strategies for mitigating the unforeseen cut in pipeline supply was to boost LNG imports, which surged by 60 billion cubic meters during the same period

It’s crucial to remember that this increase occurred alongside a sharp decline in LNG imports by China, Japan, and South KoreaAs previously mentioned, China's return to a normalized economic footing in 2023 may spark a resurgence of LNG demand across AsiaSecondly, the current low gas price levels in Europe could stimulate a rebound in natural gas consumptionOn the one hand, decreased prices may incentivize businesses to switch from coal to gas, contributing to a revival in gas-fired electricity generation; on the other hand, it may somewhat undermine household efforts and motivations to conserve energy.

From the supply side, two critical factors pose potential upward pressure on gas prices: Firstly, there are few new LNG and pipeline gas projects expected to come online before 2025. Secondly, the explosions affecting the Nord Stream 1 pipeline, coupled with Europe’s refusal to procure gas from Nord Stream 2, result in an effective daily reduction of around 15 billion cubic feet of gas supply